deviant ART

*lilykane:iconlilykane:

Lea Hates You. It's True.  

Shoutboard

OMG, HOW MANY PEOPLE ACTUALLY READ THESE THINGS???????

Disclaimer

The views expressed on this website are mine alone and do not necessarily reflect those of deviantART or my employers.

Squenix Contest Continued

Journal Entry: Sun Apr 13, 2008, 9:19 AM
Sorry, dA admin dropped the ball on this one.

1. Okay, the extended the deadline one week. Lolz!
2. The rules have been "clarified". Meaning, they're still vague as fuck, but they actually state the art will not be used. Of course, this is two weeks later, and the reasoning for the funky copyright? Still not anywhere in the rules nor disclaimer where it should be if there are going to be joint parties handling copyright. The reasoning, you have to go to a pissed off admin's journal to find out why. If it was just dA, fine. If it was just Squenix, fine. But two seperate parties, no. You have the clarify.
3. I also got sick of linking to certain journals bashing the contest. Considering spec work is something that's been going on for decades, and yes, it's a big deal. However, this wasn't worth the pitchforks. Laughing at it and giving a little warning to our younger artists to watching out for things like this, yes definitely worth it. That's why I did my little journal entry :)

Honestly, this is one of the worst handlings of PA I've ever ran across anywhere. But it's dA; I shouldn't be surprised. I'm also personally offended that the admins running the contest are surprised and butthurt that people were suspicous. Well, when you're absolutely not upfront about what things are going to used for, then duh. This site has a community filled with professionals as well as amature artists. The admins themselves run a business and some are professionals themselves. When they should not be surprised that when word something like this clearly that their peers are not going to be supportive. That's why the entries for this contest haven't been as up-to-par as some of the other contests they have ran in the past, and unfortunately, they probably didn't get the kind of quality participation they've received in the past because of that. I shouldn't have to accidentally come across an admin's journal to know why things are worded they way they are. That should've been a link in the contest disclaimer from day one :)

Anyway, my two cents. Just saying, this was really badly handled :P. And I will say, even with the "clarification" done in the contest rules, it still reeks of two companies looking for spec work, even know I "know better" supposedly. And there isn't a link in the rules nor the disclaimer for the reasoning behind the work sizes.

  • Mood: Alarmed
  • Playing: Crisis Core (ironic, isn't it?)
  • Drinking: water

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0

=Xiao-Feng-Fury:iconXiao-Feng-Fury: Apr 13, 2008, 9:54:11 AM
I'm totally convinced.
I
'm better off joining an OC tournament in hopes of getting a year subscription.

Sure, most OC tourneys are not related to a big name company, but the prizes are legit at least.

--
Matthew 6:33
"But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you."
*omegasama:iconomegasama: Apr 13, 2008, 10:53:43 AM
Pissed off Admin? Which one?

--
Callicratidas says of his beloved: " And, should a violent tyrant bind him in chains, I shall put the same fetters around myself."
~XCBDH:iconXCBDH: Apr 13, 2008, 11:36:40 AM
Heheh. You know, I think it would have been nice if they had had all the pictures and information on the game up from the get-go at least. I remember reading about it the first day, going to the page, and seeing like one picture of a building and a spiral-y. Hilarious! They should have had the disclaimer: Must smoke weed before contest makes sense.

That said though, I really don't have any other qualms with the contest itself, like some people have. You know it's like, whatever. You know what you're getting into. It's obvious they're just trying to build hype around a throwaway game of theirs anyway, and see how much easy money they can make from mutating heavily borrowed concepts into mildly ambitious gimmicks.

Kinda like using Dr. Seuss to sell another fairly typical CGI animation!

--
"You told me, never to limit myself to one style...to use any move that works...TO KEEP AN OPEN MIND!"
-JCVD
~Merillian:iconMerillian: Apr 13, 2008, 2:26:02 PM
yea I'm mad too-as for Square Enix-they could do better with this O_o
I meaaaan people don't know if its a joke,a lame contest or a mere try to advertise the game to youngsters.

and liek the deadline is pretty ridiculous.They create a game how long.And they gave 2 weekdn for the contest...duh...

Its funny how enix should learn from contests like Pepper Project-theyre not big company maybe-but they treat theyre contest proffesional.

--
psssssssssssst!!!!!!!!!!! its me....
~Merillian:iconMerillian: Apr 13, 2008, 2:26:49 PM
without straight rules,is there any chance that anyone can win ;]

--
psssssssssssst!!!!!!!!!!! its me....
*Tsuxiau:iconTsuxiau: Apr 14, 2008, 3:12:43 PM
Lol That's what I'm wondering xDD

--

I give up. This sig sucks regardless. :/
~yippy-ki-ay:iconyippy-ki-ay: Apr 16, 2008, 10:47:22 AM
Out of all the people opposing the dA/enix contest, I think I respect your opinion the most. Everyone else was acting like it's hell on earth, but your points are actually reasonable and make sense and you didn't need a 500 page journal of hate to do it. Wish there were more out there like you :]

--
"Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana." -Groucho Marx
*CabbageArt:iconCabbageArt: Apr 29, 2008, 4:07:26 PM
Yeah, it reeked of spec work to me as well. Nice to see a level-headed journal about it though.

--
"Make no mistake, those who write long books have nothing to say. Of course those who write short books have even less to say."
~Zampano, The Navidson Record